A Twilight Meal
by AP

Comment by ShutterPug:
Beautiful capture! Tack sharp focus on the deer, with a perfect DOF

Legs.
by AP

Comment by BMacD:
Hi! HereĂ¢€™s a comment from the Critique Club.

First Impression:
Nice shot!. My eye went to the runner, over to the trees, down to the sky and then down the building skyline.

Composition:
Nice framing with the trees. I really like the arch effect. Find the amount of dark trees distracting. I would consider cropping the three trees on the right. This would draw more attention to the runner.

Subject:
Meets challenge

Technical:
Nice DOF and focus. I like the details and colour in the sky and clouds. Very effective lighting on the distant buildings. Green a little bit oversaturated in the trees to the right.

Summary:
Good eye to put this picture together. Not sure about your scoreĂ¢€Â¦may have been the imbalance between dark/light and your subject. Voters donĂ¢€™t spend a lot of time looking at the picture, so 1st impression is important for their initial score.

Good luck with future entries!

Legs.
by AP

Comment by kingsley:
Nice composition. A little to dark for me.

Legs.
by AP

Comment by atupdate:
You found the perfect location for this type of image and I put this in my top 10.

Legs.
by AP

Comment by pineapple:
Nicely New York there. The sky is interesting - we have been lucky of late with that.

Legs.
by AP

Comment by FocusPoint:
I don't like the idea legs, but I love the view. Don't ask me why, when I think transportation, I would like to see a man-made vehicle rather than feet or legs... anyway, 7

Legs.
by AP

Comment by tosk:
The framing and colours are nice in this photo, but the runner seems overwhelmed by the other elements of the photo.

Legs.
by AP

Comment by ionelpop:
The sky is the best exposed in the photo and it seems at it were the subject.

Legs.
by AP

Comment by dynamomomof2:
the blue in the sky really pops out - great job

Faith in Purity
by AP

Comment by f-32:
would have also been a great duotone. Funky image, interesting technique.