Door of Wonder
by Antithesis

Comment by karmat:
I like the different colors, but the "straight" perspective makes it static to me. Maybe a different perspective, or maybe shooting just a couple of the windows have made it a little more dynamic.

The Unheard
by Antithesis

Comment by KimInNB:
This looks better in the thumbnail!! But it's not a square - it's a rectangle - and if your subject is the screaming person, then that's not a square either.

The Unheard
by Antithesis

Comment by smellyfish1002:
Reminds me of Pink Floyd, so I give it an 8!

Door of Wonder
by Antithesis

Comment by Turbotech:
Dark though very intresting.

The Unheard
by Antithesis

Comment by camelotnorth:
I like the use of the frame for your square..the colors and view of the unheard person very dramatic.

Door of Wonder
by Antithesis

Comment by teachme53:
Nice colors, focus, etc. It just needs something to make it stand out in my opinion. Perhaps a small child in front of the door, thet would not take up much space and would give the picture a 3-D look. Who knows? Good Luck. John Gill

The Unheard
by Antithesis

Comment by tiff:
you picture could have gone al lot farther, its to plain for my taste.

The Unheard
by Antithesis

Comment by Arjen:
I think this photo would be much more interesting if I could see or at least suspect what's going on behind the door! Or am I missing something?

The Unheard
by Antithesis

Comment by Martin:
excellent. great idea. 10-martin

Alright, Who's Got the Hot Milk?!!
by Antithesis

Comment by kandyj:
Critique:

Meeting the challenge: I would have never known that this photo was related to milk products without the title, and even then it's a stretch for me.

Composition:
I like the way the person that is the focal point is located in the left third of the photo and that several other persons in the photo lead your eye to him, which makes him stand out in this picture of a group. There is not only color contrast, but contrast through subject matter that tells a lot about the picture. I agree that cropping this photo vertically and including heads and feet may have improved the composition. The flip side of this issue is that the other people in the photo help to explain what is going on with this nearly naked subject, as those around him do not reflect the swimming event well.

Creativity:
I love the way you used the contrasted figures and the expression you caught on what looks to be a very candid photo. And the way you tried to link the picture to the challenge subject was really a stretch of your imagination imagination(;')

Technical Quality:
The image is clear and dof good. No visible post-processing problems. Maybe a slight increase in mid-levels or brightness may have made the contrast a little improved, and a bit less drab in color.

Overall Opinion:
Interesting image, but lack of connection to challenge theme likely hurt your score this week. Hope the guy finally got warmed up!!