Who stole the cookie from the cookie jar?
by mimsydotes

Comment by Tammer:
Wow...or should I say...bow-wow (sorry, couldn't resist) I love it! Great concept and execution. I like the color treatment you chose. I hope you get a ribbon.

Who stole the cookie from the cookie jar?
by mimsydotes

Comment by tate:
is that dog passed out from overaeating? Nice idea -- although does look spot-edited. 7

take your pick
by mimsydotes

Comment by jogee:
I pick red! I love how the red has the shine on it.

take your pick
by mimsydotes

Comment by mycelium:
yellow/orange/red is an analogous color scheme, not a complementary color scheme...

take your pick
by mimsydotes

Comment by HVGB_photos:
What a striking arrangement!

Complementary colours are pairs of colours that contrast strongly when compared to each other. Unfortunately, the red of the single apple is not the complementary colour to the yellow of the rest of the apples... you would need to have a more green tone on all the other apples to achieve the complementary pair of red/green, or a more blue-violet hue on the single apple to achieve the complementary pair of yellow/violet.

Regardless, this is an eyecatching arrangement, and it could have done well in another challenge.

take your pick
by mimsydotes

Comment by jaxed:
Great composition, the colors are a little off and washed out.

take your pick
by mimsydotes

Comment by Tammer:
I like the concept, but the orange/yellow cast is so very....bright (for lack of better technical terms), I feel the need to squint a bit when looking. Also, a bit more sharpening or focus on the red apple itself would help boost the overall appeal.

take your pick
by mimsydotes

Comment by KarenNfld:
Does not meet the challenge.

take your pick
by mimsydotes

Comment by lynb:
nic pic, but it doesn't meet the challenge

take your pick
by mimsydotes

Comment by madison461:
nice idea but technically poorly executed.