The Halloween Aftermath
by mimsydotes

Comment by GrayGhost:
Has fall colors, but a broader spectrum might be more interesting.

The Halloween Aftermath
by mimsydotes

Comment by Gallatin:
Colorful

The Halloween Aftermath
by mimsydotes

Comment by KarenNfld:
Nice and colourful, but it seems over sharpened or over saturated.

The Halloween Aftermath
by mimsydotes

Comment by tpoc:
oooh...makes my stomach hurt from the memory of all that candy! like how the silver hershey wrapper catches the light.

The Halloween Aftermath
by mimsydotes

Comment by Mr_Pants:
I feel that this has a bit of a reddish-orange colour cast to it, but that could just be my tired eyes. Strangely enough, I like the composition.

The Halloween Aftermath
by mimsydotes

Comment by aardvarkk:
great idea. the colours seem to have a yellow cast, however. i like it though.

The Halloween Aftermath
by mimsydotes

Comment by talmy:
The appearance of the lower left of the Hershey label is strange. perhaps the lighting is too harsh or it has been very oversharpened. Also needs more DOF -- wrapper in foreground, bottom-right is out of focus. Perhaps image was oversharpened to attempt to make up for focus?

The Halloween Aftermath
by mimsydotes

Comment by laug:
Looks alittle busy.

how i wonder...
by mimsydotes

Comment by philup:
***Greetings from the Critique Club***

Lets start by, does this meet the challenge...and yes, I think this is a great light on white! His expression, position, lighting is great! I notice in your comments that the b/w was not good for this challenge. I think its great for the challenge. It really sets the mood for the picture.

The only problem I can see is the blown out shirt sleeve. Its not real bad but it does pull my eyes to it. May have lost some points with the voters there.

Overall: I think this is a great photo for a very hard challenge. The boys expression looking out the window is awesome! Congrats on 35th place!!

I hope my critique helps...
Phillip

The Futuristic Slinky
by mimsydotes

Comment by Ivory:
Cool!