Happy Birthday
by gothgirl83

Comment by jemison:
small image, poor exposure, poor focus, not much care into composition.

Nightvision
by gothgirl83

Comment by cools98:
Not really close up, and the negative look is really bad. No detail anywhere. Too many areas "blown out".

Happy Birthday
by gothgirl83

Comment by k4ffy:
too small

Happy Birthday
by gothgirl83

Comment by saracat:
In order for the voters to be able to give you a really well-thought-out comment and vote, your entry needs to be large enough for us to make out the details. I cannot tell if it is out of focus or overexposed, but the apparent lack of contrast in color and shadow leads me to believe that there is something out of whack, I just can't quite tell what.

Happy Birthday
by gothgirl83

Comment by crickett:
too small, OOF,

Nightvision
by gothgirl83

Comment by HawesPhotoKC:
wow this is bad

Happy Birthday
by gothgirl83

Comment by Minstrel:
yay Robert!

Happy Birthday
by gothgirl83

Comment by anotherday:
there is not enough contrast

Nightvision
by gothgirl83

Comment by AlexMonty:
A 1 from me for a number of reasons.

1) Image is too small
2) Image appears to not fit the challenge (not a macro)
3) With the inversion comes complete loss of all details.

Going for the brown?

Happy Birthday
by gothgirl83

Comment by Talarria:
Focus could be better, as well as the point of view so you did not have that dark sliver along the top left. A photo where the candels are lit would also have more of an impact.