Summer Tanager
by Diana

Comment by katswig:
Despite the fact that the bird is bright red, it is "hard to see" because of all the other stuff going on in the picture.

Summer Tanager
by Diana

Comment by EssAreDubya:
Maybe a bit of RED boost and this goes up a notch or two.

Summer Tanager
by Diana

Comment by Germaine:
Nice picture, but not for this challenge. Needs to be sharper.

Summer Tanager
by Diana

Comment by yianisn:
Sorry, can't see how this fits in the challenge.

Summer Tanager
by Diana

Comment by geekssweet:
Beautiful color, but he seems to be almost dead center in the focal point. My eye would like to see more color contrast between the tanager and the fence.
Possibly a little tighter crop on the left side of shot. IMO.

1947 Willy Jeep (Something Old)
by Diana

Comment by JH:
You've put a lot of effort into making the *photo* look old, and that works well. But the jeep itself still looks shiny and new!

1947 Willy Jeep (Something Old)
by Diana

Comment by Neuferland:
Okay, it looks older now but, I know, those horrible buts, I'm turned off by the tilt of the shot. I keep thinking the jeep is going to roll back down the hill, but that's probably just me. It is an improvement over the original as far as what you were trying to convey (making it look like an older shot) but still lacks a punch, maybe a slight contrast bump or levels adjustment? Also, the lack of focus or soft focus also doesn't work for me on this shot, but again, just my opinion. If I had voted on the original it would have gotten a 5, this one gets a 7 for improving what you wanted to convey and a nice feel to the shot overall.

1947 Willy Jeep (Something Old)
by Diana

Comment by Konador:
I really don't like the border/vignette thingy here.

1947 Willy Jeep (Something Old)
by Diana

Comment by Judi:
Very cool.

1947 Willy Jeep (Something Old)
by Diana

Comment by Art Roflmao:
doesn't look much older than it used to. ;-) heehee. I remember the comments and debate.