RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by TooCool:
Interesting choice of what to desat and what not. I personally don't care for it. I think it would have worked better if the dogs were not desaturated and you framed them in the green also.
TC

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by Brad:
I don't know what your intent was in this. Did you plan on leaving all the green "coloring outside the lines" trails?
It looks like you may have to calibrate your monitor to me.
Have you looked at this shot on someone else's monitor?

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by photom:
I'm not sure what you are telling me with this desaturization. You've done a good job on the model, but I really don't like the grass. I'd also suggest you don't place your subjects dead center, unless there's a reallly good reason to do so.

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by Konador:
This is an unusual method of selective desaturation but it looks great. Very nice effect :)

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by Pidd:
LOL! Funny. But take out the color on the man too, I think. Why have the man in color but the dogs in black and white?

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by tyt2000:
Nice centered composition, but I don't think the brush work you did here is necessary, you could have stopped at the outlines of the person.

Good luck...

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by Neuferland:
This is a nice shot of RT and his dogs but the post processing looks like it got a bit messy, as I'm sure you have probably heard. There is so much chaos surrounding RT that it really distracts from the subjects. Maybe if RT was kneeling on the grass with his dogs and you just left his jeans or maybe the dogs, okay, not the black one, that would be an excerise in futility :) But you could bring the cropping in tighter if he was kneeling, taking out the trees in the back, they are more distracting to me, making RT and the dogs the main focus of the shot. A 4 as is

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by cbonsall:
its weird but I like it. Very intersting to see you've coloured a bit of the grass but not followed a natural line.

I really like it infact but knowing DPC sensibilities lots won't.

I'd have liked to see a bit more colour in the dogs and less on the man (I like dogs more than humans!!)

Gets an 8 from me

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by Philos:
Why did you color in the grass?

RT and dogs
by undieyatch

Comment by Gareth:
I'm not fond of the saturated grass patteren, it's a brave choice for a challenge, which I admire, but for me it doesn't work.