Bentley
by Chinabun

Comment by SandyP:
This is really good! There is SO much detail in this watch, and your focus is sharp enough to read every single bit of it. Amazing! 10

Bentley
by Chinabun

Comment by dewed:
nice and sharp..........if only the watch werent centered

Bentley
by Chinabun

Comment by docurrie:
I like the overall shot. Wish all of the back ground at the bottom of the watch had been out of focus.

Mystical
by Chinabun

Comment by Matthew:
Technically excellent. Flower looks a little lopsided to me as top petal is folded back (don't know if that is the way they come). Petal on RHS flower breaks into the DoF of the main subject matter and could be a distraction. Quite a central composition - could lose the LHS.

Image lacks a "wow" factor that the top photos have. The image is a little bit cliched: it would have to be a perfect example to do very well (and even then, would lack the challenge of some of the top ranked shots, which will lead to lower scoring).

Having said that, this has not been "slammed" - you have a majority of 5 (I read: good, but no more), 2nd ranked 6 (I read: better than average) and more 7s and 8s than 3s, and more 9s and 10s than 1s and 2s. A fair result for a picture that is technically excellent, with subject that is pretty, but not captivating.

I gave you a 6.

Message edited by author 2005-04-26 08:50:20.

Mystical
by Chinabun

Comment by bcoble:
I gave it a 7. However my guess and I could be wrong, is that even though the quality of the photo is very good, it is the content. Basically it is one color, perhaps they think it is boring. I too am not that partual to macro flower shots. I see too many and they are beginning to all look the same to me. I could be wrong?

To the Rescue!
by Chinabun

Comment by ubermoose:
I'm lovin' it. This is the most creative subbmission I've seen in ths challenge.

Bentley
by Chinabun

Comment by shareinnc:
I like the clarity of the face, but there is something distracting about the background...I can't put my finger on it.

Bentley
by Chinabun

Comment by puma:
MY favorite brand of watch. Nice take

Bentley
by Chinabun

Comment by naomik:
nice close-up.

Mystical
by Chinabun

Comment by vince31874:
This should have done better. I don't know... alot of photos got slammed.