Living behind the Sign
by arnit

Comment by moondoggie:
An interesting photo. I like it because it is different from the other submissions, but yet the out-of-focus sign in the forground is more a distraction than it is a contributing element. Maybe if it were just a little more in focus, and occupied a smaller percentage of the scene. Also, I think the huge black border is a bit of a distraction - a little too much border for this image. Still, I like it. 7 md

Got Milk?
by arnit

Comment by Sonifo:
Can't wait to see all the different takes on this one. Great shot.

Got Milk?
by arnit

Comment by sher:
splash! nice capture!

Got Milk?
by arnit

Comment by Anachronite:
hard to tell.. is that arnet or a lookalike? lol... neat idea, but we have seen this! time for something new :o) however, it is still a neat capture... that must have been a pain in the ass to get... how many times did you get milk on you? lol (8)

Living behind the Sign
by arnit

Comment by catpixel:
Scenery on hand like this gives you a huge advantage. I don't see anything achieved by throwing in a blurred sign. Looks like a spectacular landscape, with something blocking the bottom right corner.

Got Milk?
by arnit

Comment by DougPaz:
Nice knock off. I really like his expression and the lighting on the model. The biggest problem is not being able to see the bottom of what appears to be a glass in the top right.

Got Milk?
by arnit

Comment by lisae:
Arnit... I was at first kind of annoyed at the idea of such a famous photo being retaken for another challenge. But, I just looked back at "Got Toast", and read all those comments (I wasn't here for that challenge), and I realised that having another chance to do this photo and have it taken for what it is, a great idea, without all the doubt about it being faked in photoshop, must be really satisfying for you! And this time, it shows even more flair. All that milk hanging in the air, with the snow on the ground and the beautiful clouds, makes this an amazing photo. So, I'm keeping an open mind and giving it 10 :).

Got Milk?
by arnit

Comment by cvhs99:
I get it - the milk is the clouds. neat way of looking at things. The white thing (I'm guessing a pipe or cup?) is very distracting. The boy's clothing is also blends too much into the background. I would insist he wore something lighter.

Got Milk?
by arnit

Comment by kandyj:
Great shot, (again?) Where's the toast?! Colors, composition, and clarity excellent, as well as the humor. The clouds in teh background and snow on the ground repeat the colors of the milk. Great job, 10.

Living behind the Sign
by arnit

Comment by GinaRothfels:
That looks like a really nice view. It's a pity the sign is so out of focus.