In The Evening Sky
by KOKOCAT

Comment by ShutterPug:
** Greetings from the Critique Club **

I get the feeling you were going for simplicity, and that you did achieve - just does not have anything to grab my attention. It is just my opinion, but I feel a photo should say something - tell a story or convey a message of some sort. This seems to be the type of photo shot just to meet the challenge - not shot becasue you wanted a phot of this to hang on your wall or look back upon later. I have done that myself in past challenges and try to avoid that now. The colors in the sky are very pretty.

- Linda

Reflections
by KOKOCAT

Comment by Tammer:
For me, this photo would have greater interest and impace if the refelctions at the very top were cropped out. The photo itself appears grainy and out of focus on my monitor, but a good idea.

Ginny
by KOKOCAT

Comment by Napalm Nymph:
Would like to see this slightly more crisp/vivid.

Ginny
by KOKOCAT

Comment by digitalknight:
more contrast would make this really strong -

Reflections
by KOKOCAT

Comment by sanx:
Very different; I've seen many cats in the challenges, but not so much goldfish. xD Love the colors and lighting and placement. Nice perspective.

Ginny
by KOKOCAT

Comment by Refwhett:
IMO this needs a much tighter crop. The lighting is also not very good, as the image looks very flat and there are shadows on her face while the background id light (what is the main subject here). The model looks tense and unresponsive (the body language with the folded arm and her facial expression). I will have to give this a 4.

Reflections
by KOKOCAT

Comment by CalliopeKel:
Fish lover here. This is exceptional. Great clarity and color. 10.

Reflections
by KOKOCAT

Comment by mandrade:
Even though its called reflections.. the reflections on the top are a bit distracting. The fish seeing himself on the side only would have made the picture a better view i think. 6

Reflections
by KOKOCAT

Comment by stam:
I have goldfish and I love them and I love this photo!

Ginny
by KOKOCAT

Comment by Bud:
Wonderful portrait, it just seems the colors are a bit washed out.