squared
by holdingtime

Comment by mikala:
i don't find the composition very interesting.

squared
by holdingtime

Comment by Gatorguy:
The tree in the center is so dominant that there is really nothing else for the eye to explore in the photo. The result is a bit of an uninteresting photo.

squared
by holdingtime

Comment by w24x192:
To me, this image looks like it was stretched...something about the proportions are just skewed that way. In either way, I like the strong color of the sky, and that the remainder of the image looks to be B&W. It is an interesting shot, so much so that I felt led to comment (it takes something to make people stop and stay a while, so good on you for that). Have fun...good luck.

squared
by holdingtime

Comment by reevey:
Not sure the selective desat works here.

squared
by holdingtime

Comment by Katmystiry:
Beautiful blue sky

squared
by holdingtime

Comment by Strontious:
no impact, and no distinguished point of interest, i know the tree in the middle is centered, but all the other trees, which are underexposed, distract from it, and nothing about the center tree draws my eye in

Charity
by holdingtime

Comment by Art Roflmao:
Composition: 6
Technical: 5
Creativity: 4
Appeal: 4
Challenge: 1 - Very cute & all, but...
Overall Score: 3 - (weighted - NOT a calculated average)

Note: Click for info

The Neighbors's
by holdingtime

Comment by Bud:
Nice concept, the colors seem slightly washed out, but a good image.

The Neighbors's
by holdingtime

Comment by Tammer:
Now, if you had been able to catch a beaver in this shot as well, I would have bumped it up a point or two. For me, it needs another element or object to keep me interested.

Charity
by holdingtime

Comment by Melethia:
Even with the title, not sure I see a connection to the challenge, unless one of the young women is named Charity.