Still Life with Knife
by puzzled

Comment by sherpet:
I like the layout and sharply done

Color of Fog
by puzzled

Comment by UNTITLED:
I vote for the color photo. The white and purple tones really create a feeling of cold to go with snowy image. The warm pink tones in the upper corner take away a little bit from the cold feeling of the photo. I think it might look a tad bit better with the large pink area cropped out. That's just being nitpicky, excellent photo regardless.

Color of Fog
by puzzled

Comment by Floffy:
Nice lonely tree, love em ;) I think that the color version works the best.

tree_4052.jpg
by puzzled

Comment by Jutilda:
I like this one best. Really fun with the foggy white. Makes the tree truly stand out!!! Nice composition - I love negative space!

Color of Fog
by puzzled

Comment by saintaugust:
the colour version works better for me -- the foreground loses some detail in the b/w transition. also, the mood of the photo is better in colour.

Color of Fog
by puzzled

Comment by Jutilda:
I was thinking black and white!! Try it - the contrast will be great.

Animals of the North
by puzzled

Comment by SandyP:
Amy, I LOVED this one!!!! This is awesome! Great finish in a really competitive challenge! :)

Animals of the North
by puzzled

Comment by macrothing:
7 - Like this. All very good shots. Criticism; the only real 'criticism' I have had on this triptych (and I've looked at it a few times now) is there seems to be a lack of 'balance', or flow between the three, or their arrangement. Whether it is the colorings, or the 'compositions', I can't decide, but I keep thinking the 'level' (angle?) on 1 & 2 is fairly uniform, the 3rd doesn't 'suit', maybe if it were in the middle, not sure. There are similar colorings in each shot, but obviously blues/whites dominate in 1/2, but then 3 is different and not just because 3 is not 'birds'. Sorry, hard to put into words, but I tried.

Autumn Rose
by puzzled

Comment by tpoc:
The colors are beautiful, and I don't mind the natural business of the photo. That cool pink against the warm tones of the foliage gives enough of a visual jolt that I keep coming back and looking at it. The contrast in color tones makes it feel like a touch of spirng in the fall. I like it.
Jeannel

NYC from a bus window
by puzzled

Comment by tpoc:
I remember seeing this when it was uploaded. This is a beautiful b&w image. Love how small the city looks compared to the skyline. The sharpness gives the city an almost surreal feel. Very nicely done!
Jeannel