Ginsu Knife
by Bear_Music

Comment by fotomann_forever:
Robert, I can't figure out why, but the knife just doesn't look sharp to me. The edges appear soft. I can tell it's in focus because the "Santoku" is sharp.

Ginsu Knife
by Bear_Music

Comment by MQuinn:
Alright Bear my honest opinion:

First I like the symmetry, love the colors. The blue showing as a blur on the right side just above the bowl should have been fixed. Overall I really like it, my only suggestion to make this really neat would be a less vertical to the knife, a lower camera perspective would be really cool.

Ginsu Knife
by Bear_Music

Comment by jduffett:
First of all, the background: I like it a lot. The colour and the shape. The composition as a whole, I like too. Maybe too symmetric for some, but I think it works here (I guess you could say the knife is asymmetrical enough). Anyway, my problem is with the knife itself. The edges and the text are a little soft. Perhaps this was the effect you wanted, but I think in that case you'd be better off without the text. Text invites reading, and I find the text just a touch soft to be pleasing, or not soft enough to be interesting. The exposure of the blade seems a little off too. Again, it seems to be too 'middle ground'. There is a little colour/texture/detail to the surface, and I think it might have been better with all or nothing. In that sense, I think it is the slight colouring that bothers me the most, and it might be somewhat improved simply by desaturating the surface of the blade. Just some random thoughts...

Ginsu Knife
by Bear_Music

Comment by Neil:
The colors and use of the bowl are quite nice here. However, IMHO, the almost vertical knife, right down the middle, doesn't offer a dynamic image, nor does it work as well geometrically with the bowl. I can't say this for sure, but I actually think having the knife pointed down, towards the viewer, would be more dynamic, and might even trigger a very slight "danger" emotional reaction from the viewer. Another thought: It might have been interesting geometrically to have the knife just above the bowl, somewhat horizontal, touching it at the top of the arc just barely.

Just some thoughts, hard to visualize without cutting the knife out to play. The light and colors here are so wonderful though, that I'd love to see you play with this a little.

FWIW, I gave this a 6.

Ginsu Knife
by Bear_Music

Comment by DrAchoo:
I gave it a 7. Personally, I think it would have looked just a touch cooler if you had cloned out the english words and just left the japanese characters...

P O R C E L A I N
by Bear_Music

Comment by jpdeloof:
strange subject which occupies the image well, one notices the lamp very.

P O R C E L A I N
by Bear_Music

Comment by Nanate:
This is just great. How in the world did you ever come up with this idea? It is very unique.

P O R C E L A I N
by Bear_Music

Comment by nlghttrain:
great idea too bad the focus was lost on the candle

Ginsu Knife
by Bear_Music

Comment by Art Roflmao:
Shoulda known this was yours, bear. Well done. I gave it a 6. Shoulda done better, but it was a rather lame challenge all the way around.

P O R C E L A I N
by Bear_Music

Comment by JPR:
I have to give this a 10. It is perfect. static and dynamic. meaningful and meaningless. everything I could possibly hope for. thanks for making this challenge worth looking at.