A fitting place for Liberal Media
by kimybrady

Comment by techtraum:
Not sure why you think the NY Times is so liberal (and why liberal = trash), but I won't let that affect my rating. The picture is too small (use the 640 limit - it's a small limit as it is!), and the composition is dull. Otherwise an interesting idea. There appears to be areas with lack of focus suggesting shallow DOF, but maybe that was a disguised hint at the shallow POV expressed ;-).

Music is reflection...
by kimybrady

Comment by photographist:
I think that this was a good idea, but the resulting image isn't at all clear to me. It feels flat, and confusing. Obviously, this could be my impression alone, but for what it's worth...

A fitting place for Liberal Media
by kimybrady

Comment by behindthescenes:
i think i wouldve liked the picture more if there wouldve been a background full of trash and amidst all the garbage there we saw the "liberal media", it just looks too staged.

Music is reflection...
by kimybrady

Comment by autool:
Focus seems too soft. You probably tried different angles to bring out the reflection more so I won't suggest it. The dark area kind of kills what I think you were after. 5

A fitting place for Liberal Media
by kimybrady

Comment by MrYu:
*shrug* 1 from me...

A fitting place for Liberal Media
by kimybrady

Comment by wkmen:
politicallly speaking I'm with you - smal size makes it seem blurry, or at least lacking resolution for good detail or texture

A fitting place for Liberal Media
by kimybrady

Comment by Philos:
I think you have a great idea, the problem with this photo only is that it will score low here on DPC.
There's just too much rubbish in this photo to be apreciated by the masses.
If you shoot for yourself or for your own "fan-base" it's ok. But here at DPC, if you would like to "score" there are some things that you must and must not do.
No: artsy pictures, pets, dificult to understand photo's, deeper meaning.
Yes: Oversaturated, burned sky's, landscapes with sunset oversaturated with burned sky's)
I know i know, but it's realy true...

Music is reflection...
by kimybrady

Comment by MrYu:
I think submitting a photo of this kind of quality is just an insult to the viewers. I'm sure there are reasons why it came out this way, but perhaps you should pass on a challenge next time a thing like that happens.

Music is reflection...
by kimybrady

Comment by Donatien:
Took me forever to actually see what it was. Way out of focus makes it look like you took it with your camera-phone. Lots of distracting elements left even if it had been in focus. Either it's an attempt at the brown ribbon or you need to try a bit harder I think.

Music is reflection...
by kimybrady

Comment by LalliSig:
Awful shot... Nothing in focus and you can´t make out what it is, I am sorry but I can´t give it anything but a 1. I am just hoping it was intentional to get the "brown ribbon".