Boat
by ssodell

Comment by bcoble:
If you cropped out the other boats this may have meet the challenge better.Sorry. I do not believe this meets the challenge criteria.

Boat
by ssodell

Comment by Travis99:
My attention is drawn to the boats in the bg not the lone fisherman

Boat
by ssodell

Comment by jemison:
subject too centered anfd background cluttered

Boat
by ssodell

Comment by Zed Pobre:
The line sticking up in the center is distracting, and the larger boats seem sharper and more of a subject than the small one with the person.

Boat
by ssodell

Comment by train:
too much going on here IMHO to be Minimalism

Boat
by ssodell

Comment by PhantomEWO:
what is the verticle line to right of boat? An antenna?

164th Street
by ssodell

Comment by sprite777:
Um, I'm sorry, but this is still one of my favorites from this challenge... 4.7? That's a ridiculously low score for this... I think I gave you the 10 here.

Circular Swing
by ssodell

Comment by graphicfunk:
returning for comments;
A great idea with good use of sepia and attire very befitting, however, the effect failed to materialize in a convincing manner. Bumping to 6 for good composition.

Circular Swing
by ssodell

Comment by KaDi:
A classic beauty. The sepia lends to your interpretation of the challenge. With the trail o the watch was more defined, it's lost against the light background. Perhaps a shorter exposure with only half the arc recorded stopping the pocket watch in mid-air? Use of frame was probably necessary, this one is a bit heavy-handed though.

Circular Swing
by ssodell

Comment by blindjustice:
Interesting but the thick border and framing effect got to go.You don't need it- the crop is too tight on the vertical as well.