Most Choices Aren't Black or White
by alsatia

Comment by scalvert:
Good idea, but it looks like you got too close to focus. Make sure you use the macro setting for a shot like this if you have one.

In the Bright Lights of the Fair
by alsatia

Comment by FirstAid:
Is it me or is this shot a little out of focus?

Most Choices Aren't Black or White
by alsatia

Comment by Imagineer:
Challenge link: weak.

Image critique: this is very unappealing to look at. It looks like a very poorly taken shot and frankly I'm quite baffled that this could not have been improved prior to submission. It may jsut about meet the brief but what is someone to think about this? If it's not desirable as an image you will quickly tire of it in your challenge photo list.

Out-of-challenge appeal: none.

Most Choices Aren't Black or White
by alsatia

Comment by Moose101:
I think if the picture wasn't out of focus you might have had something here. But it just doesn't work for me in this stage.

In the Bright Lights of the Fair
by alsatia

Comment by redmoon:
the main problem is the lack of sharpness and focus. the angle also doesn't help matters - the fact that each jar is full of different colours is not that obvious, all you can see is mostly whiteness of the glass. getting further down, or indeed going a bit higher would probably help. i'd imagine the ambient lighting wasn't very useful, and as a consequence it would be very difficult without a tripod to get pin-sharp. conceptually, it's very interesting. 4.

Most Choices Aren't Black or White
by alsatia

Comment by Kanntara:
Nice Concept! Needs a bit more focus tho.

Most Choices Aren't Black or White
by alsatia

Comment by Gatorguy:
Unfortunately, badly out of focus.

O Tannenbaum!
by alsatia

Comment by Shadowrain:
Nice, but I think it would be better without the plant? the geode itself i like

Most Choices Aren't Black or White
by alsatia

Comment by langdon:
Severly out of focus.

Most Choices Aren't Black or White
by alsatia

Comment by Prof_Fate:
focus focus focus