Walking the Dogs
by Keith Maniac

Comment by mrorange002:
Hello there!
This is ericlimon from the Critique Club!!!

I believe this was a greatly under rated photograph. It clearly shows "implied lines" to me. The angle of the image is terrific, the silloette (sic) is perfect.

I'll do my best to give a critique on this.

First, maybe if the right hand side of the tunnel wasn't cut off by the frame, it would have given an even better showing of the tunnel. (ie: if you could see the entire end of the tunnel) This photo definately works best in BW, I can't even imagine it in color. A faster shutter speed would have helped to stop the blur in the dogs tail, but the blur does not affect the overall quality. There isn't much else to say IMO. This is a terrific photo, and I think it deserved to place ove a 6.

Keep up the good work, hope to see more of your photos placing higher in the future!

Eric

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by graphicfunk:
returning for comments.
This is just so pretty.........very smart cropping to show the breath and scope of this image. Bumping up.

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by hyperfocal:
Very interesting composition. Too bad there were no clouds. Good job. (7)

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by terje:
Nice composition.

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by Sailingduck:
lots of real estate in this one. Nice job

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by train:
Nice idea and image although it looks a bit flat in the lighting and the image is small
I do like it though 7

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by kennyt:
Very, very nice shot!

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by Philos:
Great, just great, the long horizontal road gives a sense of lonelyness.

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by Ivo:
Well composed.

Lighthouse
by Keith Maniac

Comment by just-married:
The composition here is well thought out and adds to the pleasure if viewing this image. 6, just-married