Wheelchairs on Ice
by atsxus

Comment by Mr_Pants:
The ice looks overexposed, but the shadows in the trees are great. Very difficult lighting conditions.

Wheelchairs on Ice
by atsxus

Comment by AJFI:
maybe they simply want to watch!

Composition in 3s
by atsxus

Comment by TooCool:
Sorry... I don't believe that this effect should be legal in the competitions and must vote to discourage it's use...
TC
Edited to add actual critique: I'm not sure why you chose to use the tryptych style in this image. There really is no connection to the challenge theme except that you have divided the shot into three sections. You have what is essentially an average landscape type of shot which incorporates some urban elements. By adding the horizontal bars you have not added anything to the composition. If anything you have divided the shot into a very nice panoramic style shot (top), a below average (spelled boring) urban shot (bottom), and a very bland landscape in the middle. You really didn't add any impact or pop to the shot...

Composition in 3s
by atsxus

Comment by RedOak:
I get the frame idea, which is quite unique, unfortunatly, it wouldve been more interesting if the picture followed the theme, which it doesnt. Also i find the picture a bit dull in colours (i understand its during winter). The picture is nice and well leveled, but just doesnt follow the theme or brings the exclamation it should.

Dying Light
by atsxus

Comment by JPR:
Is this the TZ bridge from Dobbs Ferry?

Composition in 3s
by atsxus

Comment by visaksen:
great - fine idea

Wheelchairs on Ice
by atsxus

Comment by tommyd65:
I'd like this photo more if it wasn't as washed out.

Wheelchairs on Ice
by atsxus

Comment by notonline:
Its not very clear altho it is one of the funnier shots I have seen in this challenge. I find that the signs are a little to small to see well and the contrast is over powering. It also looks that the photo may be a little over sharpened. Good luck in this challenge.

Composition in 3s
by atsxus

Comment by BrennanOB:
nice shot and a clever use of editing tools to shoehorn this into the challenge .

Dying Light
by atsxus

Comment by Tirpitz:
I think you should have lowered the horizon and make the tree frame the sky even more. Good light though.