Mother's Loveby
cloudsmeComment by ursula: From the Critique Club:
Composition: I think the composition is excellent, but I also think that it is the kind of composition that is going to get a lot of mixed reactions. One of the mother's eyes is "cut off", and that is going to bother a lot of people. The only thing visible of the child is the hair, and that, again, is going to bother a lot of people. But for your presentation, the composition is excellent.
Technical: Again, very good work. The only addition that might help is a catchlight in the eye.
Post-processing: Beautiful! I see no problems with it.
Challenge: It meets the challenge topic well, actually right on. You got quite a good score for it, although probably not as high as you wished. I think what hurt is the mixed reactions the photo produces - too many people hung up on the close crop.
Hope this helps.
If you have any questions/comments, feel free to contact me. Take care,
Ursula