In The Garden
by sibeling

Comment by macrothing:
7 - Very nice scene. Criticism; would like to have seen the "point of interest" more defined, contrasted possible. Perhaps a slightly tighter crop down the bottom to avoid that 'thing' bottom left of the statue. Technically, while no 'expert', seems to me like you have gone for two rules here, 'bottom third row' and top right intersection, difficult, but especially for the Challenge, I would like to have seen an even stricter 'adherence' or 'emphasis' using either or both of these rules.

In The Garden
by sibeling

Comment by Elaine:
I like that all the greens are different enough that they don't all become a solid backgound.

In The Garden
by sibeling

Comment by Riponlady:
beautiful composition but a bit too green for me on statue, meets challenge

In The Garden
by sibeling

Comment by chele:
good DOF, nice textures and colors. good job.

In The Garden
by sibeling

Comment by kloughe:
Very nice 8

In The Garden
by sibeling

Comment by Jutilda:
Totally monochromatic. This is good because it sends your eye to the statue instead of a bunch of colors and your eye not having a place to rest. I might've upped the green sat a bit but overall, this is different and quite pleasant.

In the Presence of Saints
by sibeling

Comment by JeffryZ:
I would have like the first saint a little more in focus too. But good otherwise!

In the Presence of Saints
by sibeling

Comment by TheresaA:
Nice clean image with lots of good perspective. Good Job!

In the Presence of Saints
by sibeling

Comment by Jutilda:
Interesting - and I like the title. I like that the man is focused and the saints are not
I recognize St. Frances of Assisi - who's the other one? Nice linear quality to it with the architecture. Perfect use of black and white.

In the Presence of Saints
by sibeling

Comment by CrystalFury:
would be better if you cropped it to just the left half perhaps