Mr. Saturday Night Special
by nards656

Comment by Crisik:
I thought this was a top ten stuff - but still I'm glad you made it above 5 as planned :-)

(has a dark comic book feeling, both harsh light and sharpness make the atmosphere)

Mr. Saturday Night Special
by nards656

Comment by Mustardhead:
I thought this was one of the strongest pictures in the challenge so I gave it a 9.

Very gritty, excellent treatment, perfectly in keeping with the subject.

Chopin
by nards656

Comment by Strontious:
sorry, but no good

Mr. Saturday Night Special
by nards656

Comment by loseme:
Good use of light painting. Nice work, great composition.

Chopin
by nards656

Comment by e301:
In such a very clean graphic composition (and it's nice that you've understood the comkpositional demands of the crop), a bit of cleaning of your subject would go a long way - the fingermarks and dust are a shame, and easily dealt with in advanced editing. Lacks the real fizz of good soft lighting to give the shot impact, I think.

Chopin
by nards656

Comment by skewsme:
Good idea... perhaps a piano vs. organ might have come off a little better for this title?

Chopin
by nards656

Comment by ergates:
Very sharp. Not enough "spark" in the picture to push it to a top score. All imho obviously. Good luck!

Chopin
by nards656

Comment by hotpasta:
just lacks a bit of inspiration to me...while it's a nice shot, it doesn't really jump

Mr. Saturday Night Special
by nards656

Comment by sherpet:
To sharp for me.....

Mr. Saturday Night Special
by nards656

Comment by kari1:
This is an interesting and very grainy picture.