black and white
by visaksen

Comment by deapee:
I see a lot of blues and a brown leaf. Sorry, but this doesn't meet the challenge in my eyes.

black and white
by visaksen

Comment by eirasi:
blask and white and blue or is it perhaps just my eyes or computer?

black and white
by visaksen

Comment by Zap228:
Not black and white enough. I understand what you were going for, but the road isn't completely black. a simple conversion to grayscale on photoshop or your digital editting program would greatly improve the photo. It still meets the challenge, but not to what was expected.

black and white
by visaksen

Comment by magnetic9999:
im giving this a low score because this is not 'black and white photography'

black and white
by visaksen

Comment by Quadrajet:
It looks like this shot wasn't desaturated, as I can still make out some color in it.

black and white
by visaksen

Comment by Dr.Confuser:
Not B&W.

accordion with indicator
by visaksen

Comment by redmoon:
i didn't vote in this challenge, but i acknowledge your grief for it is a wonderful shot. i love the angularity of it, and visually it's very pleasing. only slight criticism is that the focus seems ever-so just a little bit too soft. . but that's the ONLY quibble, and even that might be down to my eye sight as no one else has mentioned that. this would not look out of place being framed and hanging on the wall of a diner. hand on heart, i'd have given this a 8 or 9.

accordion with indicator
by visaksen

Comment by MrYu:
This is awesome as it is. But, imo, it would have been even better if it was a horizontal shot with the orange light in the lower right golden section point or thereabout.

Unfortunately, i didn't get to vote on it for the parts challenge, it would have gotten a 10 from me.

accordion with indicator
by visaksen

Comment by Imagineer:
:: Hello from the Critique Club ::
............................................................

This has been horribly under rated in my view.

It has strong composition, it's an imposing subject, it's well lit and very striking. Why it rated so low truly astounds me.

By way of critique I find it difficult to pick fault, but I just wonder whether cropping the bodywork on the left would make the image stronger?

Don't be put off by the result - this is good stuff.

Cheers
Jon

Communication
by visaksen

Comment by TooCool:
Where did you find an old school rig like this?
TC