broken ice edge
by clictacamera

Comment by Bear_Music:
Too much jumble, no focus on the ice edges that are broken. Needs some work with a levels layer.

wind'n my pants
by clictacamera

Comment by sailracer_98:
This image does capture wind, but I think an alternative approach to the subject might yield a more interesting result. The dull concrete, snow and ice don't make for a very photogenic background for this image. The glare coming off the ice in the upper left is a bit of a distraction. The static pose of the subject also leaves something to be desired. Perhaps showing the person struggling to walk against the wind with a cloudy sky or wind whipped tree in the background would add some emotion to the photo and help draw the viewer in. A shallow depth of field to blur the background if there isn't an interesting alternative might also be a good approach.

wind'n my pants
by clictacamera

Comment by purna:
boy!!

wind'n my pants
by clictacamera

Comment by snackwells:
Lacks fine detail. Appears to have been sharpened too zealously evidenced by strong halos around the edge details. I think you chose an interesting way to represent wind in this photo, and to your credit, it was a creative attempt. Unfortunately the execution was hampered by technical deficits.

wind'n my pants
by clictacamera

Comment by alma04:
i just cannot commend

wind'n my pants
by clictacamera

Comment by vontom:
Composition: 4, Technical: 5, Appeal: 3, Challenge: 6, Overall Calculated Average Score: 5

broken ice edge
by clictacamera

Comment by strags:
I'm kind of of the view that a picture shouldn't need the title to explain why it fits the challenge. That said, it's a fairly decent shot.

broken ice edge
by clictacamera

Comment by Art Roflmao:
Composition: 9, Technical: 8, Appeal: 10, Challenge: 7, Overall Calculated Average Score: 9

broken ice edge
by clictacamera

Comment by glad2badad:
interesting...would have been really fun with some early or late day sunlight.

broken ice edge
by clictacamera

Comment by TooCool:
I'm not sure that partially formed is the same as 'broken'...
TC