Window Revisitedby
MartinComment by karmat: CRITIQUE CLUB CRITIQUE
by karmat
COMPOSITION
Framing the shot with the "frame" really adds to the composition of this shot I think. It draws the viewer's attention and focuses it on the subject of the picture. It feels a little off to me, maybe if the camera perspective was a little more to the left. Inside the frame, the rolling hill makes for some nice motion.
TECHNIQUE
The focus seems a little grainy, but I think that may add to the shot (more on this later). The grays, which would normally make for a drab shot, really add to the effect of this shot, as well, I think. I'm thinking I see some noise in the sky area, I don't know what your shutter speed, etc was, so I can't suggest anything in that area, but if you haven't ever tried NEATIMAGE or other noise reduction filters, they can really clean it up.
OVERALL EFFECT
A bit more fog, and your subject would be hidden completely! When I saw this shot, I immediately thought of the book "Wuthering Heights." It just has that dismal, gloomy, somber, mysterious aire about it. Nice work.