Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by W.R.Miller:
I really like your idea here and do enjoy this photo. MO is that it is just a bit soft. Perhaps focus is on the grass at the bottom in the foreground and not on the subject? Either way I still like this. Meets that challenge very well. Good luck with the challenge!!!

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by notonline:
in my opinion the title needs work. also the focus is off. maybe a sharpen effect would have helped.

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by peecee:
wants to be a little better focus on the main subject.

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by CDS:
IMO - it appears that the camera focused on the vine in front of the main subject.

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by jlgarrote:
it´s a little out of focus, isn´t it?

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by orussell:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background 6
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing 2
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc. 6
How well does it meet the challenge: 8
Total Averaged Rating(Rounded) 6
I would have scored this higher if your focus had been on the vessel. As I see it, your focus is sharpest on the forground grass. A little shallower DOF with focus on the milk can would have been much better IMHO.

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by thunderbug:
out of focus

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by oskar:
I don't understand why you choose to have the grass in the foreground in focus but not the milkcan or the Ivy.

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by Prof_Fate:
focus not sharp onthe can or ivy...grass on bottom of pic is in focus though. unnerving to look at.

Ivy in Milk Can Planter
by whagerbaumer

Comment by pogboy4:
the milk can is out of focus, looks like your autofocus focussed on the grass instead of the milk can. unless...that is what you were going for...