Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by bvy:
(Know that I only vote in even numbers.)

A four for you. A clever composition that wants to be abstract. The lighting is dull, though, and the impact just isn't there.

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by tvsometime:
Based on the plot summary (I haven't read the book) there is no apparent connection to this crime novel, only a literal reference to its title. The shot is well detailed and moodily exposed and I like the POV to add some instability/tension - but this old organ has me thinking more Broadway theatrical horror (as in Phantom of the Opera) than modern Welsh noir thriller. 5

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by RyanW:
simple, straightforward but in a knowing smile sort of way.
an 8 from me

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by Cory:
Initial Reaction: An organ...
Suitability for Challenge Topic: It seems this book is about a Russian poet found dead in Scotland. By a retiring detective. Ok, so sure, organs are used at funerals, but... That's a pretty weak connection.
Aesthetic: Lint on keys, and a bit dark overall. Nice DOF.
Needs Work: Exposure, concept
Final Thoughts: Not a bad image, just the wrong challenge, or book choice.
Score: 4

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by RKT:
4...I'm not familiar with the story, but I just don't find this image very engaging. I think my main problem is the light...it could use more pizazz. It looks like it's being lit with an old school fluorescent tube.

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by Tiberius:
Good close up, well lit and exposed but soulless, static 4

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by eniko:
I don't get a feel of a crime novel. I like the aged look, but feel that it could be a tad brighter. A 5 from me.

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by daisydavid:
Nice close up of the organ, not much connected to the novel that I know unless that is a Scottish organ produced by Russian businessmen, but I've only read the plot summary. 5.

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by lunachicken:
Not a clear tie to the book, except for the title. The layout and DOF are nice, and the tones very realistic, but it doesn't wow me. 5

Exit Music by Ian Rankin
by MAK

Comment by Tiny:
Its ok but ultimately does nowt for me.4.