Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment by nards656:
Revisiting and explaining my lower scores - I hope to be helpful, not insulting.

I only rated this a 4 because I really can't decide what you are up to. If this is a remake of an obscure AA print, I apologize for not understanding. You are very correct that there are excellent examples of most of the zones in the different stars, and I see that, but the photo holds absolutely no interest for me. There are no compositional features, no leading lines, no shapes, and no textures, all of which I regard to be crucial to a good black and white photo. So, if you mean this humorously and I missed it, I am sorry.

Best of luck!

Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment by NovaTiger:
Sorry, but I find this pretty boring.

Winter Falls
by charliebaker

Comment by pinkzilla:
i Love it. The winter falls at some snowy place but it is sweet.

Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment by ralph:
not very 'AA' ish at all...

Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment by PollyBean:
It's original!

Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment by photographist:
Original

Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment by tazza:
LOL!

Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment by phreakon:
Its nice that your camera picks up clean star images, but c'mon, you could have submitted anything else in black and white, and it would have been closer to something Ansel Adams would have done.

Winter Falls
by charliebaker

Comment by EaThis:
to me this is more of a black and white than a light color on white background as the challenge suggested.

Celestial Zone System
by charliebaker

Comment by IceRock:
Did you find UFO ?