Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by jmsetzler:
Greetings from the Critique Club...

I understand your theme for this challenge, even though I think it is a very weak one. In my personal opinion, this photo is nothing more than an attempt to meet the challenge. There is no creative use of lighting. There is no creative use of color or black and white. There is no creative use in perspective. There is nothing here that draws my attention in a positive way. I think that black and white was a bad choice for this image. The contrast and tonal range is rather flat, wich rarely lends to a good monocrhome or duotone image.

Better luck next time :)

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by jsmiley:
hahaha. thats forked.

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by Rgarcia:
Interesting idea, nice choice for color.

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by mitsukai:
Poor quality, and weak concept.

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by notonline:
Nice concept but the glare from the flash on the upper side of the plate brings your eye to that instead of the pictures meaning. Its also unbalanced/ uneven and a bad crop.

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by scalvert:
That's funny!

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by thebone123:
Similar idea to my own Faux Pas! By the way the light on the plate gives it an optical illusion. ie: is the plate unside down?

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by cmangis:
A kind of out-there idea, but more appropriate than some others for the challenge. I like the textures you've captured. The picture is flat and monotone, though; I just don't want to spend much time with it.

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by Knotdamoma:
This photo is just plain not appealing to me in any fashion. It's not a technically bad photo, although it could be a bit brighter, and I do see the "conflict"...it's just not esthetically pleasing to my eye.

Can't Fork This
by reagent74

Comment by leskataus:
Interesting.