Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by Focused:
Wow! both conceptually and technically awesome! Congrats on your well-deserved ribbon!!

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by Slohands:
Not "surreal" as I would define the word, but an interesting photo for sure.

Message edited by author 2005-03-21 20:32:38.

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by Sonifo:
Very creative! Congrats.

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by magicshutter:
I don't know. Seriously creative and even more well done. I thought I was creative until I started seeing this sort of thing. My only question is how the hell did you come up with the idea, let alone the mechanics of making it so bad ass. well done.

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by JPR:
sweet! great score and deserved blue. i was expecting you to win this challenge after our breakfast conversation. too bad my photo of you didn't get the brown like i had suspected, cause that would have been pretty cool. :)

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by conceptphoto:
Yeah, I think that we should just scrap rules.

But, wait... isn't that what advanced editing is for? Oh yeah!

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by beaflies:
Rules?! Personally I score for: skill, creativity, effort, fitting the Challenge, and grab-you appeal. This "bright idea" fits hugely in all categories. But what it really comes down to is that we are here to share and learn photography, and make great photos! Not to learn how to follow rules! Thank you so much Shannon for sharing!! and daring to skirt the boundries!
The reason this fits in the category of "Surreal" to me is that one, it could not be real, and two it makes you scratch your head.
This was my only 10.
Pleased that I knew how you did this, but bummed I did'nt try to enter something. You Challenge this newbee to reach higher! :)

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by conceptphoto:
So, WAS the moon yours? lol.

Message edited by author 2005-03-18 23:59:07.

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by TechnoShroom:
I didn't get around to voting on 20% so my vote didn't count but I do think this is a ten. Great creativity. A big sigh and a shake of the head to all those who consider this "cheating" or somehow against the rules or even spirit of the rules. This is no different than using a backdrop in a portrait or still life.

Nightbulb
by scalvert

Comment by george crawford:
I loved this picture and it diffently deserves the ribbon, but does it not mean there is a gap in the rules. I far as I was aware no photoshoping etc (apart from levels, curves etc.) is allowed. Could we all just manipulate all our images and take a photo of the screen on Basic Editing?