Brooklyn NY
by TLL061

Comment by FromDaRock:
Nice image, although not much underexposure. I see a lot of darks, but not much actual underexposure.

Brooklyn NY
by TLL061

Comment by FrankRobinson:
Tricky. This is a lovely shot, balanced, sharp etc, but I would say it is a perfectly exposed night shot rather than an underexposed shot.

Brooklyn NY
by TLL061

Comment by tanguera:
This is the second image I've seen of this memorial, and both are crooked. THAT is strange!

Never Forget
by TLL061

Comment by Adz:
Amazing image and great composition. Love the cloud movement and the reflections on the water.

Never Forget
by TLL061

Comment by tanguera:
This image seems tilted to me. Since the beams are meant to be vertical, I think it is a significant flaw.Exceptional clarity and detail though.

Never Forget
by TLL061

Comment by william88:
Beautiful and much better than the other one. 10

Never Forget
by TLL061

Comment by LadyK:
this is a really touching image, but im sure its getting hammered for being too much land. personally, its not enough sky for me and would receive a lower vote because of it, even though i consider the photo very well done and very meaningful.

Never Forget
by TLL061

Comment by lawrysimm:
I'm saying the cityscape here is the main subject, with the sky in the supporting role, the opposite of the challenge brief. I think it's a fantastic image though so I am torn. Nonetheless, I'm knocking a point off for my perceived DNMC. Plus, I think a slightly tighter crop losing the railing on the far left would be tidier. There are a few NYC shots in this challenge, this is one of the nicest.

Never Forget
by TLL061

Comment by malcjsmith:
Very well executed but the image slopes left to right. With a straight horizon this could be a winner.

Brooklyn NY
by TLL061

Comment by scooter97:
Love this shot. Could benefit from a darker sky. It is really a great shot. I hope to get one this good at the GTG.