Old Rotten Machinery
by gwsallen

Comment by liberty:
Neat image, like the colors, 7.

Old Rotten Machinery
by gwsallen

Comment by digifotojo:
That really is! lol But it's nicely portrayed...I particularly like the composition, your use of contrasting forms. The warm colors are appealing in spite of the subject matter. 6

Old Rotten Machinery
by gwsallen

Comment by brentaugusuts:
Creativity = 1.5
Composition = 1
Lighting = 1
Contrast = 1
Focus = 1.5

Allen & Esther
by gwsallen

Comment by purpleflutterby13:
Greetings from the Critique Club.

I really like this image - good idea, well executed.

The composition is perfect - the white space around the rings just makes the shot. Simple and effective, with good lighting and a good background. I like the slight blue/greenish tinge, and the level of sharpening seems just right - the shapes are clear, but still have a nice soft focus fitting for the subject.

There seems to be a bit of noise in the lower right corner, maybe running it through Neat Image would have helped?

Anyway, very good image. The only thing is - the topic has a great emotional potential, which I'm not sure this really taps into... It looks perfect and stylised, but maybe a bit cold, I'm not sure anything genuinely draws the viewer into the idea.

That's about all I can think of. PM me if you have any questions.

Jelena

Allen & Esther
by gwsallen

Comment by JeffDay:
very nice, super clear

Allen & Esther
by gwsallen

Comment by HeiSch:
"still" together? sorry could help but asking. just the right exposure to not blow it out. good job

Allen & Esther
by gwsallen

Comment by KarenNfld:
Lovely simple image, in my top 10

Allen & Esther
by gwsallen

Comment by sherpet:
Simple and to the point.....

Allen & Esther
by gwsallen

Comment by Blackbox:
How very sweet - I hope the other voters understand. 10

Allen & Esther
by gwsallen

Comment by Fairfield20:
Not