Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by danbachmann:
this probably would have been great in better lighting conditions

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by Go-KL:
nice colours

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by cghubbell:
Good composition - nothing distracting me from the subject.

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background 3
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing 9
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 3
How well does it meet the challenge: 10
Total Averaged Rating 6.25 Dick
Your composition is the weak point here. You have a wonderful subject, work with it, different angles, distances, less busy foregrond/background. it should pay off.

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by whagerbaumer:
Nice colors. I cannot make up my mind whether the tower is integral to this structure of whether it detracts. I would love to see this photo without it. I like the dark behind the window, but find this side of the barn a little dim to occupy so much space in the photo.

A 5.

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by CDS:
Very nice. I love the way you have pulled out the red doors. IMO - the crop is a bit tight on the top. Would like to have seen the entire wind vane.

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by omnibus:
The aging/derelict mood has been nicely captured - certainly meets the spirit of the challenge even if it is of "rusty" wood. Might be improved slightly if the very left corner of the roof wasn't cut off and if the color balance was a bit warmer.

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by photom:
The entire image below the sky line is real dynamite. Nice exposure, stong subtle colors - wonderful lines on the barn. Now just figure out a way to make the sky a nice blue - and remove that tower on the upper left while you're at it. Nice submission - I enjoy looking at it.

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by doctornick:
Lightning not right.

Decaying Farm
by Polar7

Comment by melismatica:
This is a beautiful old barn. There's nothing really wrong with this composition. It's a nice rural landscape. But I'd be inclined to close in on the section with the door and the window.