kettle river
by spease

Comment by Imagineer:
Lovely scene. I think this would have more effective if you'd managed to get close to the water for a more dynamic viewpoint. As it is, the shot appears to be from eye level and makes it less potent. Centred comp is also a bit weak.

kettle river
by spease

Comment by kennyt:
beautiful spot for a photo. this seems out of focus to me tho

which way should I go
by spease

Comment by Tiberius:
Nice snapshot. Nothing more...

kettle river
by spease

Comment by Node:
Its a lovely scene but I don't like the 2 trees on the right hand side, maybe a slightly differet angle or tighter crop.

kettle river
by spease

Comment by terje:
Nice view, but add more saturation and contrast and this will be greatly improved in my humble opinion.

kettle river
by spease

Comment by Sailingduck:
I like the direction of the shot and the potential colors of the trees and water, but there seems to be a yellow/green cast to the entire picture.

which way should I go
by spease

Comment by Imagineer:
Challenge link: weak.

Image critique: poorly focused, dull composition and lacking in detail and interest. (Sorry, but this is the epitomy of a slapdash snapshot).

Out of challenge interest: none.

mpls police band
by spease

Comment by Pooba:
Guy in top right is distracting.

kettle river
by spease

Comment by puma:
Enter your comment here, and then cast your vote.

film to digital learning
by spease

Comment by Konador:
B.O.T.P.A.C.
Bottom of the Pack Analytical Comments

Every challenge I am going to leave comments on some of the photos that finished at the bottom of the pack. I will try and explain why I think the photo did not do well in the challenge, which will hopefully result in increased rankings in your future photos.

-Ben

1) Lighting. The lighting seems just normal, as if you've placed the items on a table and taken the photo. A lot of people like lighting in still life photos to add something to the photo.

2) Size. The photo is too small to evaluate properly. Most voters like to see the full 640 pixel limit to be used.

3) Interest. There is not much in the photo to bring attention to it. People like something interesting to look at and/or think about.