Not At All
by GP

Comment by Bibliophile:
Technically good photo, but has nothing to do with rusted. Taking a picture of the opposite of the challenge is a waste of voters time, please don't do it again.

Edit: And I'd rather people didn't private mail me during voting. Afterwards would have been fine. And just to let you know I'm not changing my vote in either direction.

Not At All
by GP

Comment by cghubbell:
Great combination of curve and straight, bright and dull. I think this failed to meet the challenge's call to create an image around somethign rusty, but in general it is an interesting picture.

Not At All
by GP

Comment by sailracer_98:
Interesting shot, though you lose points from me for not shooting something rusted. I don't know if it is better or worse that you allude to understanding the challenge in your title but still submit something off topic. On technical merits, I like the lighting on the metal, but the dirty, stained tiles detract from the image somewhat.

Not At All
by GP

Comment by ronlcox:
Where's the rust?

Not At All
by GP

Comment by tolovemoon:
Good outake! Thats the way to be different I give it a 10!

Not At All
by GP

Comment by whagerbaumer:
This does not respond to the wording of the challenge. The sidewalk is unappealing, and the composition of the arc if I blur the background does not quite appeal.

A 2.

Not At All
by GP

Comment by briphoto:
good point

Not At All
by GP

Comment by orussell:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background 5
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing 6
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc. 4
How well does it meet the challenge: 0
Total Averaged Rating(Rounded) 4

Not At All
by GP

Comment by Donatien:
Voiding the challenge in the title doesn't do it for me. Even apart from that the shot doesn't hold that much anyway.Could have been average with rust in it - but I'll put this out of topic, sorry.

Not At All
by GP

Comment by hannafate:
It's a great photo of whatever it is. However, "lack of rust" wasn't one of the options in the challange.