Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by soccerdad:
Sorry, this is too abstract for me, though I am sure others will love it.

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background 8
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing 8
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 4
How well does it meet the challenge: 8
Total Averaged Rating 7 Autool

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by vtruan:
Not fond of your coloration, it maybe artistic, but rather boring. 4

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by lockjawdavis:
I'm no fan of the processing done here, I'm afraid.

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by scottwilson:
If you had not messed this up in PS it would have been a good photo. I am sorry but I donĂ¢€™t see any photographic integrity here at all.

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by e301:
I think I'd personally have coloured it all in, rather than leaving the land in monochrome. There is some appeal for me in the effect, probably especially in the shade of red you've chosen ... but perhaps (and I'm searching for the right words to express my feelings about it here) it's rather more about the effect than the photograph.

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by photom:
Nice capture - interesting concept. The black and white buildings with the red work well, but do seem a bit "unnatural."

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by jodiecoston:
I don't care at all for the unnatural colors. It looks like this was a lovely shot to start out with.

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by alanfreed:
Is this near a nuclear power plant...? :)

I'm not sure I'm fond of the effects here. I'm not sure I understand the point behind them (I feel there should be a *point* to doing something like that).

Tonawanda: Gateway to the Erie Canal
by lwkimages

Comment by willem:
I don't like the color combination at all.