Fall's Catch
by Neil

Comment by Dr.Confuser:
I like the photo a lot but, for me, the vignette is too harsh. A bit more subtle on that and i'd give it a point or two more.

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by GregoryB:
I like this one better than all the rest Neil. The golden tones of the city lights work better for me with the sun still setting. I don't think the observation deck to the right detracts form the overall scene and I do like the wider angle.

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by Yo_Spiff:
I think I actually prefer this one to the entry (though they are both great). I like the wider view and the golden glow from the windows in this version.

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by PHOTOKID:
All I got to say is wow, I love it! The colors, the details of the lighting in the buildings. It all flows so nicely together. I think I have found a new fav!

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by lynnesite:
I agree, the people pull my eye a little, but not the structure, and not until I've looked at it for a little while. So as a print, yeah, I'd probably choose to burn in that lower corner a bit. Love the width and the perspective.

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by VitaminB:
I agree with Melethia... this one is better because of the wider view. I am unsure about the observation deck however. There is a lot going on in the shot, so I didnt notice it at first, but even now that I know its there, I dont find it a distraction because it isnt very bright or prominent, so I still end up looking at the buildings/sky/sunset.

What building where you on when you took this photo? (yes... If I am ever in NY I hope to try it myself)

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by tinky2:
The colors in this are gorgeous! I don't mind the viewing area at all. It adds a bit of interest to it with others enjoying the view. I prefer the sky in this one with the brighter spot of yellow, but the other pic is phenomenal as well.

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by Melethia:
1 - I actually prefer this one to your print one. Why? Because I LOVE the wider view. To me it has more impact and you get a wider, fuller view of that gorgeous sky at sunset. 2 - I don't mind the observation deck, and not sure you should darken it - it may draw more attention to it if you do. Really is a stunning view and you sure picked the right time to go freeze your fingers off to shoot it. Heckuva nice outtake.

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by Kelli:
I don't necessarily think the viewing area detracts, but the people there do a bit. Maybe clone them out? This is certainly beautiful! Vibrant, almost volcanic colors! I'd be hard pressed to put them in order of preference, they all rock!

Manhattan Lights
by Neil

Comment by cgino:
Wow, hard call since they are all fabulous! I like this new one best, though, with the canvas version second best. For some reason I like the golden lights better, maybe I equate the color warmth more with sunset.