Heads or Tails?
by soup

Comment by Gil P:
The shot is great...but it's hard to say if this piece is actually in movement at the time of the shot...there is not physical evidence for that. (but I will trust it was)

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by dagaleaa:
a different approach indeed!!

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by Gordon:
Only the title really drags it back in to the challenge for me. Low score.

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by mrorange002:
I'm sorry,
I just don't see how this is naked? Becasue theres no bun? It's a good picture, but I really don't think it fits into this challenge. Sorry

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by whatdewuc:
thats a different idea of the word "nude". I guess in a fact that a hotdog is sorta nude without a bun.

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by wingy:
This doesn't fit the challenge.

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by frisca:
I rated this quite low because I don't think the hotdog is naked. Its dressed with condiments. I think anything but a nude human form was either going to have to be very clever or extremely well done to get past the initial thought that "nude" means unclothed person. I just don't think that happened here.

Edited to add: I can appreciate it has no bun. ;) I know that was why you chose this subject and composition, but as I re-visit this shot, I wish the plate was not OOF because it feels like its going to hit the viewer, and I just can't find a lot in this image that speaks to me and says something about the topic or makes another message known. I know these are very subjective criteria, but its a subjective vote for me and I am trying to relate to you why I gave this shot the type of score I did.

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by Article19:
?

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by Chez:
Hmmm, I'm gonna give you a 5 for cheek

Naked Lunch
by soup

Comment by mhoogendyk:
Not a nude. Almost gross, if you think about how long it sat there while someone tried to focus on the front edge of the dog. Obviously got kinda cold. :-) Nothing to rate positively - other than they did get the detail on the 1/2 inch DOF. Guess I could have given a 2 for that. But, no ... not a nude.