Xander's blue eyes
by Neat

Comment by roz:
very cute Anita .. another gorgeous child portrait .. and perfect for the challenge . :)

Untitled
by Neat

Comment by roz:
loving the pic . the drama and sense of foreboding ..
thinking there should be silhouettes of crows flying around ..
Edgar Allen Poe-esqu .. pretty sure i didnt spell that correctly ...
thats ok .. i'm sure you'll forgive me because i'm giving you a high vote . ;)

The place where we stayed
by Neat

Comment by noraneko:
Great processing choice here

Xander's blue eyes
by Neat

Comment by spencelg:
My favorite in this challenge.

Annie
by Neat

Comment by nam:

Originally posted by Bear_Music: . . . I'm with Posthumous on this. Mine was one of the low scores. For me the spirit of "shoot from the hip" is sort of a "flawed spontaneity" and this shot's too perfect to qualify even assuming Anita was running backward, holding the camera low, and using no viewfinder. It's clearly an "intentional" shot in that sense.

Sorry to admit that I did not vote on this challenge :( - but I would have struggled to find a "fair" score for the same reasons. The struggle would, of course, have been because it's a delightful, beautiful, fresh, capture. As such, I would not have given it below a 5 and would probably have settled on a 6; personally, that's what I do for wonderful photos that I feel don't meet the specific challenge. But I would have reserved my 7-10 scores for something else.

Annie
by Neat

Comment by Bear_Music:

Originally posted by posthumous: Originally posted by GolferDDS: Well done Anita. Those low scores are disgraceful! Those are probably DNMC scores. I for one felt this didn't meet the spirit of the challenge.

I'm with Posthumous on this. Mine was one of the low scores. For me the spirit of "shoot from the hip" is sort of a "flawed spontaneity" and this shot's too perfect to qualify even assuming Anita was running backward, holding the camera low, and using no viewfinder. It's clearly an "intentional" shot in that sense.

Annie
by Neat

Comment by posthumous:

Originally posted by GolferDDS: I do not know how you can positively determine that this was not taken from the hip? Innocent unless proven guilty!

this is not the US judicial system. I don't whine when a voter assumes my blurry shot was not deliberate.

Annie
by Neat

Comment by GolferDDS:

Originally posted by roz: Originally posted by GolferDDS: Originally posted by posthumous: Originally posted by GolferDDS: Well done Anita. Those low scores are disgraceful! Those are probably DNMC scores. I for one felt this didn't meet the spirit of the challenge. I do not know how you can positively determine that this was not taken from the hip? Innocent unless proven guilty! i heartily agree Larry .. quite a few times i've had a comment by a person making an assumption that was incorrect .. and given a lower vote accordingly .. and we wonder why so many ppl have left dpc .. not only the assumptions .. but how one person can change the entire outcome of a photo by giving a very high or very low vote .. the voting system just doesnt seem to be working anymore .. worked fine back in the day with more ppl .. are we dying here .. :(

Thank you Roz,
Please see my new post on the Forums concerning voting.

Annie
by Neat

Comment by roz:

Originally posted by GolferDDS: Originally posted by posthumous: Originally posted by GolferDDS: Well done Anita. Those low scores are disgraceful! Those are probably DNMC scores. I for one felt this didn't meet the spirit of the challenge. I do not know how you can positively determine that this was not taken from the hip? Innocent unless proven guilty!

i heartily agree Larry ..
quite a few times i've had a comment by a person making an assumption that was incorrect .. and given a lower vote accordingly ..
and we wonder why so many ppl have left dpc ..
not only the assumptions .. but how one person can change the entire outcome of a photo by giving a very high or very low vote ..
the voting system just doesnt seem to be working anymore .. worked fine back in the day with more ppl ..
are we dying here .. :(

Annie
by Neat

Comment by GolferDDS:

Originally posted by posthumous: Originally posted by GolferDDS: Well done Anita. Those low scores are disgraceful! Those are probably DNMC scores. I for one felt this didn't meet the spirit of the challenge.

I do not know how you can positively determine that this was not taken from the hip? Innocent unless proven guilty!

Message edited by author 2024-05-27 22:59:40.