Moose Meadows
by PAN

Comment by Nuzzer:
Greetings from the Critique Club.

First impressions are that the size is too small. I know it's a panorama but any "wow" is lost by the small height.

Technically this seems ok. At this size I struggle to see a lot of detail to be able to comment. It appears a bit dark overall but as it's 2am that's to be expected. Given this thought I'd expect there to be some element to focus on - there isn't.

Artistically this could be great - at the right size.

In summary it's all about size. Any drama or "wow" in this shot was lost in the small height :(

Feel free to PM me if you have any queries.
Gerry

Moose Meadows
by PAN

Comment by Paul:
A nice panoramic but these really don't make too much sense to offer up within the DPC image size limits.

Moose Meadows
by PAN

Comment by Ja-9:
you know, I think this has soooooo much potential...but it's sooooo small in size...can I ask what happened? Unfortunately I can't see much of the detail (I'd like to). It appears to be a very beautiful spot. Your sizing is what will hurt you in this group.

Moose Meadows
by PAN

Comment by MaryO:
I like what I can see of the relative light. At 800 pixels wide this crop is just too short for me to see much detail.

Moose Meadows
by PAN

Comment by hotpasta:
the scene is good, but looks soft...unfortunately these thin landscapes don't work with the 800px limit as they are too small

winter wonder
by PAN

Comment by pjd101:
house ruins the photo. 4

winter wonder
by PAN

Comment by littlegett:
This has the potential of a nice clean postcard look. With the white trees and lights in the building. Though for me, it does not have enough. It is lacking something to really take me in.