One Tiny Seed
by Keith_W

Comment by cutout:
what gives you a 10

Beautiful Silence
by Keith_W

Comment by jjstager2:
Heavy on the mid-tones in this B&W. Nice peaceful and serene mood evoked here.

Beautiful Silence
by Keith_W

Comment by Ja-9:
to me this seems grainy and needs a touch of straightening

One Tiny Seed
by Keith_W

Comment by Ja-9:
now that is hard to capture...I've tried with milk weed...ya...forget that...

Beautiful Silence
by Keith_W

Comment by Deen:
The boat is great, this photo would be flat without it.
top 5

Do they look good on me?
by Keith_W

Comment by JulietNN:
Hi from a member of the Critique Club!

You asked that your photograph be critiqued by a member of the Critique Club in this challenge.

Well WOW, you got no comments on this shot!!! Well, let me be the first to comment,

This is a fair shot, a hard shot to get. I think that what happened here is that you have just a head popping out of no where, it almost looks like it is stuffed to be honest. I think that if you had this in a portrait mode, it may have scored a little better.

Your sharpness is spot on, your colours are good. You have a nice blurred background going on which compliments the great sharpness you have going on with your subject.

Keep on shooting

Beautiful Silence
by Keith_W

Comment by KarenNfld:
Nice vantage point but the photo looks flat and I don't think B&W is doing this any favours.

One Tiny Seed
by Keith_W

Comment by moosh:
If I had my wish, you might have cropped this image centered on the seed alone . It is lovey but the twig in the upper left pulls my eye from your focal point. I like the photo but based on the challenge I couldn't rate it higher. Nice work.

One Tiny Seed
by Keith_W

Comment by Coley:
A very thought provoking image. Well done

One Tiny Seed
by Keith_W

Comment by SoulJance:
love how you captured the seed in motion. If it was just the black background and not that twig i would have scored it much higher.