Rock Climbing Comp
by power47

Comment by sarampo:
Great moment, I would have increased the contrast a bit to make it more dramatic :)

Rock Climbing Comp
by power47

Comment by Ja-9:
I really like the clarity and intensity of this shot...excellent

Rock Climbing Comp
by power47

Comment by Yo_Spiff:
Just the face on it's own is worth a high vote.

Rock Climbing Comp
by power47

Comment by s3th2000:
lol justin, i like the editing

Rock Climbing Comp
by power47

Comment by burfino:
This is a fantastic shot! From experience, I know how tough it is to shoot in a climbing gym. The lighting looks so even I find it hard to believe you used flash, but I also don't see much grain if it's a high ISO. How did you pull this off?

Rock Climbing Comp
by power47

Comment by HarveyG:
Sorry doesn't portray enthusiasm to me, more like pain and effort.

Rough Seas
by power47

Comment by Jedusi:
Very cool shot - I would perhaps desat the jetty slightly - but ptherwise very cool.

Rough Seas
by power47

Comment by MarioPierre:
I agree, the DQ sucks but it doesn't take away from the fact that this is simply an awesome piece.

Rough Seas
by power47

Comment by IreneM:
The DQ's a bummer but your image is outstanding.

Straight And Narrow
by power47

Comment by ericwoo:
Hey there from the Critique Club

First of all, congrats on a new personal best. Its always nice to see a new image sitting there atop the previous high scorers. Nicely seen and nicely presented.

My thoughts on the image: I am not normally fan of infrared images. However, I like the capture here in the fact that there are details that scream infrared while the overall image retains a nicely toned black and white feel.

My ideas for improvement: Honestly, as far as a nicely done infrared image, there is hardly anything that I could suggest for improvement. I like the perspective. I like the tones you captured. I like the overall exposure. The composition is surely a great strength of the image as well. It does a wonderful job of drawing me deep into the image.

Where I would have/did score this entry: I did not vote in this particular challenge, but this would have been somewhere in the 7 or 8 range for me, depending on the strength of the overall challenge. I do like it, and I think that the voters scored this one appropriately. Well seen, well captured, and well presented. Nice work

Thank you for the opportunity to provide a critique on your entry,
Eric

Message edited by author 2009-12-04 05:18:10.