Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by floyd:
Im afraid I dont undertstand your concept for this one. It sure looks like a thin piece of ice. But Im not clear on what it's about.

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by mci:
the lighting here is really harsh, and you subject isn't really very interesting. i'm not sure i really get the connection to the challenge, either, but i don't take points off for that. you might want to crop off the top corners where your pan ends, and try to get more natural lighting instead of bouncing the harsh flash off the metal surface.

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by mjcecil:
interesting subject, though a bit confusing.

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by HBunch:
This is a little bright at the top. Maybe you could have tried to reduce the light a bit by placing something between the light source and the subject. I have heard that a thin cloth or a thin paper placed between the light and the subject helps to reduce glare and help from getting a too bright look. You did a good job of taking the photo so that we can tell exactly what it is. Even without the title, I still think we would be able to know what it is. Good luck with the challenge.

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by normw:
Too close, it is hrad to tell what we are looking at

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by wenyao:
good idea, but maybe you could have positioned a light source to capture light reflections off the ice to make it more attractive? The grey's kinda dull here..

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by henry00:
glare, subject not clear

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by psychephylax:
Ok, I see...new ice is usually thin...There's a connection to the challenge...but it's very hard to tell that is ice in the picture...Actually it looks a lot like wax. And, the bright spot right above it is a bit distracting. An original idea however...

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by Kaz:
I like the concept, but your lighting is a little harsh.

Thin Ice
by GeneralE

Comment by titotapado:
Is that really ice?