Dueling Bridges
by GeneralE

Comment by toeknee:
I get it! Nice. I'm a musician and I wasn't even thinking about this bridge. Good job.

Sliver of Sky
by GeneralE

Comment by robbieh:
This almost looks like someone's legs.Very unusual.

Trouble In Paradise
by GeneralE

Comment by DougPaz:
Greetings from the Critique Club };-)

Initial thoughts
Interesting composition, beautiful shot, color could be either more or less saturated.

Composition/ Content
The biggest thing I notice is the fact that the shot is very "middle ground" on the color scale. It is almost grayscale or black and white. It seems that either more color or a true B & W may have worked better. I like the way the flowers complement the razor wire, good eye there to see it.

Background
Once again, the color thing. A blue sky would have been so nice here in the background. A true B & W wouldn't have made it necessary.

Camera Work - Technical
Focus seems excellent especially on the wire. The wire does feel like it is moving down a bit to the right but I think that is actually the barbed wire under it. A tough decision there.

Digital Processing - Technical
The only things I might have changed is to possibly crop it up just a little on the bottom, and I would have used a darker border. Just my opinion.

Fits The Challenge
Fits the challenge but a bit of a stretch. I think the flowers kind of overpower the wire with a "Good over Evil" kind of message and that probably hurt your score some.

My Opinion On The Photo
I originally scored this shot a seven which is on the high side of your scores. I think that it meets the challenge but could understand how everyone didn't get it. Good job, and keep up the good work.


I would be happy to talk further about this shot if you would like to contact me.
DougPaz

We'll Spring Ya, Humpty!
by GeneralE

Comment by Maverick:
after voting on all the images, I noticed that this is the exact same subject as "humpty dumpty sat in a cell" right down to the colored blocks = P
I would have preferred a smaller aperture to get the bars in focus as well as the egg. Also, the color balance seems rather warm.

We'll Spring Ya, Humpty!
by GeneralE

Comment by Dustin:
Good job. Nice pic.

We'll Spring Ya, Humpty!
by GeneralE

Comment by UberFish:
see my comments on the other lego shot.

We'll Spring Ya, Humpty!
by GeneralE

Comment by DennisF:
This is exactly the same set up as "Humpty Dumpty Sat in a Cell". (Except for the eye in the back.) What gives? This one is exposed a little better than the other one.

Leading Lanes
by GeneralE

Comment by dacrazyrn:
Very interesting lines throughout. Get that feeling of going nowhere when I get on those things. But then I am kind of a hick. (C: Too bad not a clearer day

Leading Lanes
by GeneralE

Comment by CreativeFlyPhoto:
there are plenty of leading lines in this photo .. but they lead you out of the image .. not into it .. could be a shot to recreate for bridges though :)

We'll Spring Ya, Humpty!
by GeneralE

Comment by jmsetzler:
poor humpty :( - setzler