The light pillar
by prperold

Comment:
Just beautiful. Wonderful sense of depth in this sweeping grandeur. Amongst best in challenge. I see it finishing in the top 10 with a good chance of a ribbon. 9

Masked
by Ivory

Comment:
Beautifully executed. Nice sharp detail. Great use of lighting. Amongst best in challenge and imo will finish in the top 10 with a good chance of getting a ribbon. 9

The Volcano
by heidahb

Comment:
Breathtakingly stunning and dramatic image. This is certainly my favorite in the challenge for the Blue ribbon. 10

Aramis - 60% of the time it works every time!
by mileskea

Comment:
Congratulations on a still pretty good 30th place. Imo it should have finished much higher up. I gave it a 8. But of course I am no expert when it comes to judging catalog shots and reading through the comments this image received I am learning a lot about what can make or break a really excellent catalog shot. That's why this site and these challenges are so good for improving one's photographic skills and eye.

rain-x
by sfmorris

Comment:
Congratulations on a still pretty good 24th place. Imo it should have finished much higher up. I gave it a 9. But of course I am no expert when it comes to judging catalog shots and reading through the comments this image received I am learning a lot about what can make or break a really excellent catalog shot. That's why this site and these challenges are so good for improving one's photographic skills and eye.

Her Secret
by vikas

Comment:
Congratulations on finishing in the top 20. Imo it should have finished much higher up. This was my only 10 given in the challenge. But of course I am no expert when it comes to judging catalog shots and reading through the comments this image received I am learning a lot about what can make or break a really excellent catalog shot. That's why this site and these challenges are so good for improving one's photographic skills and eye.

End Dry Skin... with the Nature Collection ® by Bath and Body Works
by Lydia

Comment:
Congratulations with a very good top 20 finish. You were amongst best in challenge for me and I was sure this one would ribbon. It should have finished in the top 5 at least imo. Very well executed.

Edited: Spelling error.

Message edited by author 2010-03-29 05:22:10.

With Love
by sekarmalathy

Comment:
Congratulations with an excellent top 10 finish.

Instinct
by Lutchenko

Comment:
Congratulations with an excellent top 10 finish.

Seiko Coutura
by Lonni

Comment:
Congratulations with an excellent top 10 finish.