Almost Time
by colorcarnival

Comment:
Because the texture of the clockface is so cool, I'd like to have seen your depth of field extend through the entire image.

Wynken, Blyken, and Nod... and Clyde
by vawendy

Comment:
Very cool image.
Total nitpicking here- there's something odd about the left side of the frame and a portion of the bottom of the frame. The tone is different for some reason.
Great shot though.

Golden Ratio - Finger Prints
by chummiphotography

Comment:
Shots like this really demand sharper detail than you've managed here. Stopping down will help you with shots like this, as well increasing your contrast. You do have some cross lighting working to help define things, but it could be exaggerated more.

One Man's Home is Another Man's Treasure
by nickyb

Comment:
This would've been a great entry in the Weston Challenge we had awhile back. I'm less fond of the shots that are strictly still lifes of whatever naturally occuring examples there are of phi, but this one really is done splendidly. Nice job, one of my tops.

Unfurling Tree Fern
by yakatme

Comment:
Very nice- this makes me think of an issue of NG. I really like the lighting on this.

041 a
by mbrutus2009

Comment:
I like the lighting on the clouds on this a lot, and the stretched out pier. The sun has blown in an unappealing way though, which is a bummer. Otherwise, I really like this. I personally enjoy the choppy waves. I like the energy and liveliness that they add, instead of a tranquil feel. The clouds curving around the sun above the pier and the water together really make a feeling of impending action.

Magic Tree
by colorcarnival

Comment:
Is this the tree that you had in some other photos?

"Resignedly, beneath the sky, the melancholy waters lie..."
by Bear_Music

Comment:
Sorta strange image. I can't really put into words why I like this, but it was the one that drew me the most. Good job.

So lovely was the loneliness...
by nickyb

Comment:
Nice capture of the feeling here. Sky seems a bit crazy around the trees, but overall I like this.

Here’s Johhny!
by P-A-U-L

Comment:
I voted, and I was one of your low votes.
I voted it such because the desat felt contrived and what was left seemed overdone, as well. Very artificial looking.
I'm not normally terribly fond of photos of children, so there's gotta be a significant connection to a moment conveyed, and I don't particularly get that here. There is no context conveyed, which is crucial for a successful candid. I would also question the "candidness" of this one, but that's a whole different argument. It's also in the awkward overlap between sharp and purposefully blurred. It's soft, but it looks soft not because you wanted it that way but because that's all you could do, unintentional, unconnected to the feeling you're trying to give the viewer.