Should I ?.... Shouldn't I ?...
by Gatorguy

Comment:
Challenge link: clear and humourous.

Image critique: quite dull, but it's well focused if poorly lit and, consequently, the colour is flat and unappealing.

Out of challenge interest: none.

Pasta choice
by Gabriel

Comment:
Challenge link: OK, slightly humourous but quite weak really.

Image critique: quite bland and flat. Lighting is too head-on and this could have been creatively shot as well as meeting the brief.

Out of challenge interest: none.

Shall I take the Lens Cap off??
by SteveJ

Comment:
Too late now. : )

One Of Many. Why?
by Mark of SRQ

Comment:
There's something inherently peverse about clicking this '10' button for an image which displays such tragedy. This is just so desperate and, despite frequently reflecting on how lucky I am and helping a few charities, this really pricks my conscience. Very difficult shot for you I'm sure.

Sahara2
by Natasha

Comment:
Perfect image.

Illusion in Black and White
by gerdagrice

Comment:
Great composition, contrast and tone. Very dynamic, appealing image.

Lunch time
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Ridiculous position!! This voting was always going to be misguided though!! ; )

Lunch time
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Very unusual take on the challenge and an effective one too. You've done well to get this close and it makes for an interesting POV and composition. Unlike many in the challenge you have brought some creativity to the image rather than simply portray some objects lined up.

Thursty?
by vasilkovaya

Comment:
As a set-up shot this is technically OK, but I have to ask 'why?'. Yes there are gallses in a row but this seems to be still life without purpose - other than to fit the challenge. I would prefer to see some meaning or intention behind the shot to make it hangable or at least a creative solution.

It's nicely lit and composed but otherwise there is nothing here to motivate me.

one line
by docpjv

Comment:
That's a very long set of eyelashes!

The palid flesh tones here make me a feel a bit unwell and for me this is a bit unpalatable to look at. The lines are perhaps implied but also very literal so overall this doesn't do it for me. Focus is too soft and background is a bit messy for a shot like this too.