Canoe on steady water
by Harlequin

Comment:
Hi from the CC Club

A very good photo, it is sharp, clean and clarity is excellent. Just needed to flip the photo so he was going upwards. The eye tends to want to look upwards and wants a leading line upwards.

The water drops and leading lines of the water that you have going on here are really excellent, very clear. I am surprised at your placement and thought it would score higher than this.

PM if you have any questions

Message edited by author 2009-08-08 08:54:55.

Decorative Footwear
by cbondar

Comment:
HI from the CC club,

For your first entry this is very good!! Well done

1st Impressions, it is very dark, the lighting is dark. In post processing you could have used the shadow highlights, exposure and or brightness, using the unsharp would have give you a little edge too. . Your leading lines are excellent.

Overall, if it was just a tad lighter then I think this would have scored higher than it did.

Great job Cant wait to see what else you produce!

Shibshib
by Timosaby

Comment:
HI from the CC Club

Very nice placement for your shot, it is deserved!!!

I love the details that you have captured here, sharp , clean and clear. You DOF is good, would have liked to have seen it without the heel of the other shoe in the shot. Did you try it with just the front shoe, that would have been interesting.

The heel is a little blown out, so watch out for lighting. There is also a bump of white near the front of the shoe that is distracting. What is the white plastic looking thing on her foot? Is that part of the shoe?? It almost seems out of place with all the intricate details that you have with the beading etc.

Overal, a very pleasing shoe and foot, well done!!

Going down
by gmink

Comment:
Hi from the CC Club,

Well, technically, the horses above the colt are above him and you are above him. I'm afraid not far enough above him. It is important to read the challenge descriptions and there are always threads about the current challenge going on. These you may find helpful for ideas and more indepth discoussions about the description of the challenge. Try isolating the colt the next time.

The colt is in sharp focus, just has a rump in the way of his rump, play around with positioning and you will be surprised at what you may find. You have good clear clarity going on throughout the photo, you AP was perfect, ISO and Shutter spot on.

Post Processing, don't be afraid to play with selective colours and the black and white. The shadow highlights will give more contrast as well.

PM me if you have any questions

These Boots Were Made for Splashin'
by dswann

Comment:
HI from the Critique Club,

What in the world would you want me to say??

Clarity is sparkling
Sharpenes is cutting
Colours are stunning
POV is spot on
DOF is dreamy
Boots are too kill for
Leading lines lead
Waterdrops out drop IreneM
A wife that would do this for you

Priceless!!

Message edited by author 2009-08-06 14:40:21.

Out Danced...
by landon1013

Comment:
Hi from the CC club,

A good idea for this challenge!

1st Impressions, the lighting is very strong in this and has blown out several areas in the shoes, a less bright light or hanging something over the light would have diffused the light enough to give it a smoother glow versus a full blown spotlight. The heel on the mans shoes is almost green from the light adn there are various blown out areas on the womans shoe. In post processing for the problem lighting, you could have gone with a touch of the exposure and contrast, brightness, and or shadow highlight.

The table seems tilted which you could straighten out. The edge of the table and your background is very prominent which in affect cuts your shot into two halves, having the backdrop on the table would have eliminated this problem. Then of course your back drop is a little wrinkled, which again is a slight problem.

One tip for your backdrop, is some large stones laid at teh bottom of your sheet, this will pull it taut so it is less wrinkled. Helpers are always good if you can get them to sit still long enough, they can sit on the back drop pulling it taut. Candy always works well as bribes!

A closer crop could have helped here too, I usually make a tube out of my hand and look through it just to see if it makes a difference being cropped.

Pm if you have any questions

Rainbow Sandals
by unyielding_sense

Comment:
Hi from teh CC CLub,

Nice shot here, you do have a slight glare which could be avoided by a little diffusion, or less direct light. The focus is a little off in this shot, but the colours are brilliant and playful . you pov is good and you have some brilliant leading lines,

keep on shooting

Neist Point Lighthouse located on the Isle of Skye in Scotland
by lucinka

Comment:
HI from the CC CLub,

Well, it has been said gorgeous shot, the leading lines are stunning and lead to you to the coupe de grace at the end. I can see the horizon though and it is tilted, but it is so barely there it is not even thought of.

Title is a little long, but with a shot like that who cares!!

well done, a very nice job

Laid to Rest
by SoulJance

Comment:
Hello from the CC Club,

How funny, I did the same exact shot!!!

the over all impression i am getting from this, is the placement could have been different. Play around with your props you will be surprised at what comes about. Having the dead sunflower lower would have seperated the two. DPC expects photos to be tack sharp, so in post processing try to sharpen a little at a time until you get the desired affect.

There are no details in the petals which probably hurt your score a little and it seems over saturated.

When you are working with a desk lamp, try different angles, don't be afraid to have it over the top, laying on its side, hanging off your shoulder etc. I think some of the problem may have been that you had your exposure at 2 seconds, this will let in a lot of light and it shows on your petals.

Feel free to pm me if you have any questions

full spectrum bouquet
by posthumous

Comment:
CC Club here,

OKay I am going to go out on a limb here and guess what you where thinking when you took this shot.

IT was once alive, vibrant and full of life, then it died, but now it can make life again with the seeds from the flower heads. So in fact you have really gone for life, death and life again. Nice job!

You are tack sharp on the orange flower and its leaf, which drifts off into a smooth blur. I think the green background is not working in this shot as it is very vibrant, maybe toning it down a little?

The composition is tilted, which I actually like, I like that it inst straight on, that would make for a boring shot.

I think and believe, this is exactly what you wanted to shoot and processed.