"Finally!" he said
by liberty

Comment:
A little kinky here. I do like your take, the photograph is very good, and I have to admit, this conveys silence. Probably not really very Zen, but, hey, it's only a photo challenge.

Serenity
by davisambrose

Comment:
Seems a little over-something. Oversaturated on the greens a bit, and oversharpened to where the trees look like they were 'shopped in to the pic. Edges seem a little unrealistic is what I think the problem is for me. I think the basic image is good, however. I'm divided on this one, but I will err on the positive side.

Big Blue
by Lgraber6109

Comment:
Hate to tell you, but this is likely to get DQ'd for selective editing. The induced blur is pretty obvious. Sweet car however, and a valiant effort to deal with the background clutter that is hard to avoid in car shots. No vote, comment only.

0221
by jdannels

Comment:
I like this one better than the actual entry, which got a 7 from me. Reminds me of the speeder bike scene from Star Wars.

Spun
by jdannels

Comment:
Very cool. I was really curious how you did this.

Never welding story
by ekmai

Comment:
You didn't get an in-challenge comment from me because I liked it. It has a feel of a documentary about it. This was one of my favorites. I gave it an 8.

MC Escher
by vawendy

Comment:
I told you girl, you are going to be a ribbon hog. You seem to have a style that people like. My vote was a 7. As I said in the score thread, lack of a comment from me indicates either I didn't vote, or I gave it a vote on the high side.

Message edited by author 2009-06-24 01:04:03.

Wrestling with Steel
by citymars

Comment:
Congrats on the high placement and especially for beating yourself! It's always a rush to get something new on your profile page, especially in that #1 spot!

I gave it a 7, BTW.

Message edited by author 2009-06-24 01:01:08.

- Working Round the Clock -
by andrewt

Comment:
Pretty darn good showing for a shot you were not thrilled with! I want to be able to do lousy shots like you do someday.

buick.jpg
by Jdroullard

Comment:
Probably would have given it a 6. I like the sharpness and detail. There is a little background clutter, but I know from my own efforts that minor background stuff is hard to avoid unless you can stage the shot to suit. My solution is usually to get down very low and try to make the sky the background. Doesn't always work 100%, but it helps.