The Smoker
by pjd101

Comment:
Like it for the most part, but I think it could probably benefit from a little more separation between the subject and background.

For King And Country
by Covert_Oddity

Comment:
I think I recall this from a side challenge. Covert_Oddity?

Useless
by hojop25

Comment:
Not sure what you did with the PP on this, but it comes off to me as over-something'ed.

Mr. Coffee
by Brent_S

Comment:
Creative use of a reflection. Like it.

oh boy!... FOOOD!
by FocusPoint

Comment:
Funny stuff! Some problems that I think will hold it down, however. The texture of your background paper shows up as a graininess similar to ISO noise. (I've done it myself. It looks smoother than it is to the camera.) Since this is an advanced editing challenge, you could have used some selective editing to smooth it out.

Best and worst time of your life
by irish_jemima

Comment:
I've got to assume you didn't understand the challenge topic. In addition, it comes off as just a snapshot, and there is an excessive amount of JPEG compression that is taking away a lot of the detail in this. Compression kills detail. Always use the least amount of compression you can get away with and still slip it under the 300k challenge limit.

Just the Natural Good Humour of the Woodwork
by raish

Comment:
I'm afraid this one is not coming off to me well. The photo itself seems a snapshot and the placing of drawn eyes and nostrils on paper does not seem to me to suit the concept of the challenge. Without that piece of paper, there would not be any face in this scene.

sometimes we get to see what we've lost
by posthumous

Comment:
Excellent! I'm curious if you created the paper face, or just happened to notice it in the crumpled paper and decided it would be a good entry.

Grinnin' Grill, Grrrrrrrrrrrr
by karmat

Comment:
I like the view and treatment, though I think it may be cropped a little tight.

Frowning Hearts
by BrianR

Comment:
The faces were already painted on these mugs, so I'm not sure if it really suits the spirit of the challenge.