Abandoned
by hokie

Comment:
This is an interesting shot of plant life... since the plant is the subject of the photo, I'm not sure of your intentions for showing 'something old' in this photo. I can see that the building in the background is old, but it is secondary to everything else in this image... - jmsetzler

Another Year Older
by Corey

Comment:
This is a nice family album photo but it doesn't show me anything 'old' for the challenge... - jmsetzler

Antiquated Arrangement
by Gene L.

Comment:
very nice still life... i like your composition on this one... the contrast offered by the different color of the book adds a 'unique' bit of color to this image... :) - jmsetzler

Seventh Street Grille
by mcrochip

Comment:
If this place is old, I would have tried to capture its age with a different camera angle... When I look at a building from this angle, I think cutting the entrance way out of the photo is not a good idea. This photo also needs some more contrast and sharpness to come off well... - jmsetzler

Carousel Horse
by gigageek

Comment:
nice still life :) In this particular image, I believe that a darker background would work better. This would offer a greater contrast between your subject and the background. - jmsetzler

2nd/3rd century AD
by stephan

Comment:
Congratulations on a phenomenal photo... I love the composition AND the lighting here... the darkenss adds a great sense of 'old' and 'foreboding' to my interpretation of this image.... These old statues are beautiful. I wish I had the opportunity to make photos like this in America. Our doesn't even date back this far :) Great shot... = 10 - jmsetzler

Beyond Repair
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
Interesting photo of something 'old'... The subject may be old, but the photo lacks visual impact for me... there is no 'wow' factor... - jmsetzler

EncRust
by willsy66

Comment:
Whatever this is... it's certainly old. The strip of clear focus across the center of the photo doesn't work very well. This shot needs either more depth of field or a different camera angle. The image lacks punch... - jmsetzler

Isn't dad too old for these toys?
by lcgleah

Comment:
I would much rather have seen something 'old' in the photo rather than a play on words in the title for the challenge... - jmsetzler

Weathered
by sohr

Comment:
This is one of my favorite photos this week... the mood of this is completely 'old' and you have done a great job of capturing the challenge... The color toning you chose accents the age of this scene very nicely as well. I'm giving this photo a 10, but I still have a personal preference critique... I wonder if it would have been possible to shoot this from another angle... Possible the exact same angle viewing from the right side rather than this side... I think that being able to see the front of the carriage would be a nice enhancement.... good shot :) - jmsetzler